Open daily 12-6pm. Schedule a complimentary consultation with us.
Open daily 12-6pm. Schedule a complimentary consultation with us.
Matrimony
White Diamonds
Alternative Diamonds
Gemstones
Wedding
Shop All
Jewelry
Gifts Under $1500
Rings
Pendants
Earrings
Shop All
Collections
Bubble
Cati + Cathedral
Dew
Melee
Pave
Rock + Pebble
Sasa
Silk Line
Sky
Til Death Do Us Part
Toi Et Moi
Umi Pearl
Shop Collections
Designers
Akiko
Ariko
Casual Seance
George Plionis
Nishi
O Channell Designs
Olivia Michaels
RA Metals
Ruowei
Tricia Kirkland
Yuna Li
Shop Designers
Custom
Custom
Wedding + Engagement
General Jewelry
Stone / Gold Recycling
Create Your Own
Information
Client Gallery
General Pricing
Material Options
Stone Sourcing
Repairs
School
Private Workshops
Create Your Own Course
Bench Rental
Information
Pandemic Update
Gift Certificates
Youtube Tutorials
Policies
Info
Login
Register
Login
0
Cancel
Matrimony
White Diamonds
Alternative Diamonds
Gemstones
Wedding
Shop All
Jewelry
Gifts Under $1500
Rings
Pendants
Earrings
Shop All
Collections
Bubble
Cati + Cathedral
Dew
Melee
Pave
Rock + Pebble
Sasa
Silk Line
Sky
Til Death Do Us Part
Toi Et Moi
Umi Pearl
Shop Collections
Designers
Akiko
Ariko
Casual Seance
George Plionis
Nishi
O Channell Designs
Olivia Michaels
RA Metals
Ruowei
Tricia Kirkland
Yuna Li
Shop Designers
Custom
Custom
Wedding + Engagement
General Jewelry
Stone / Gold Recycling
Create Your Own
Information
Client Gallery
General Pricing
Material Options
Stone Sourcing
Repairs
School
Private Workshops
Create Your Own Course
Bench Rental
Information
Pandemic Update
Gift Certificates
Youtube Tutorials
Policies
Info
Login
Register
White Diamonds
Alternative Diamonds
Gemstones
Wedding
Shop All
Gifts Under $1500
Rings
Pendants
Earrings
Shop All
Custom
Wedding + Engagement
General Jewelry
Stone / Gold Recycling
Create Your Own
Information
Client Gallery
General Pricing
Material Options
Stone Sourcing
Private Workshops
Create Your Own Course
Bench Rental
Information
Pandemic Update
Gift Certificates
Youtube Tutorials
Policies
My cart (0)
Call
718-387-6200
Contact
info@fitzgeraldjewelry.com
Store info
Daily, 12pm-6pm
Directions
243 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
243 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Daily, 12pm-6pm
Alternative Gemstone Engagement Rings
One of a kind and unique gemstones sourced around the globe for an alternative sheen like Emeralds, Rubies, Tourmaline, Sapphires, and more stones!
Pave / 4mm Rosecut Milky Diamond
$1,035
3 Wishes / White & Yellow Diamonds
$5,100
50% OFF
Split Set / Green Tourmaline
On sale
$978
50% OFF
Lollipop 2 / Rose Cut Salt & Pepper Diamond
On sale
$1,650
50% OFF
Lollipop 1 / Rose Cut Milky Yellow Diamond
On sale
$1,125
Pave / 6.5mm Blue Sapphire
$3,000
Nishi
Cabochon Ring / Emerald + Diamond
$2,490
Dew 16 / Aquamarine
$1,930
Dew 14 / Bi-Color Sapphire
$1,850
Melee E5 / Sapphire
$3,000
Melee E5 / Rhodolite Garnet
$2,770
Melee 65 / Bi-Color Sapphire
$1,950
Show more
1
2
3
4
Next
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Refine by
Clear all
alternative engagement
aquamarine
beryl
bi-color sapphire
blue
brown
casual seance
champagne gold
cluster
colored diamonds
designers
dew
diamond
diamonds
emerald
emerald cut
engagement
engraving
garnet
gemstones
geometric
gray
gray diamond
green
green gold
grey
grey diamonds
grey gold
in the studio
iridescent
lollipop
melee
milky
milky diamonds
mixed stones
moonstones
newly added
nishi
old european
one of a kind
one-of-a-kind-ring
orange
palladium
pave
pearl
pebble
pink
pink gold
pink sapphire
pm star
po
po star
prong
purple
rainbow
recycled
red
rings
rose gold
round
ruby
salt and pepper
salt and pepper diamond
sapphire
spinel
split set
stackable
tanzanite
til death do us part
tourmaline
umi
white
white diamond
white diamonds
white gold
yellow
yellow diamond
yellow gold
yellowish diamond
Home
—
Alternative Gemstone Engagement Rings
Sort by
Refine
Cancel
Apply